The Dollar Then and Now Highlights Why the Current Inflation Has Been Different from the Previous Bout

February 20, 2023

The dollar was a poorly bid currency during the high-inflationary period of the 1970’s. In the wake of World War Two, a new international monetary system based on fixed dollar parities and dollar-gold convertibility was established, and it performed well in the 1950’s and early 1960’s. Difficulties arose in the second half of the 1960’s as inflationary pressures first emerged, creating inflation disparities between  major countries and a series of chronic U.S. trade deficits. The so-called Bretton Woods system proved too rigid for the new macroeconomic environment, leading to dollar devaluations at end-1971 and again in mid-February 1973, followed by a shift to floating exchange rates in March 1973.

A series of inflationary cycles with higher U.S. highs and higher lows continued through the 1970’s, culminating at a CPI peak of 14.6% in April 1980. Inflation fell to 2.5% briefly around the middle of 1983 but spent much of the 1980’s above 4.0%. The dollar’s most important relationship of that time — its value against the Deutsche mark — depreciated almost 57% from DEM 3.65 in 1970 to DEM 1.576 at the end of 1987. Another major relationship involved the Japanese yen, against which the dollar imploded over 75% from 360 yen fifty years ago (January 1973) to 79.85 in April 1995.

The dollar performed well in the late 1990’s, boosted by relatively strong U.S. economic growth and doubts that the experiment in a single European currency and unified monetary policy would succeed. By October 2000, the 2.377 DEM-translation value of the euro was roughly 51% above its end-1987 low. There would be another significant fall of the dollar amounting to somewhat more that 40% against the euro between its high in 2000 and a low in 2011, but the next eleven years saw considerable appreciation. At 0.9589 euros per dollar at its high last September 27, the dollar was 51.4% stronger than its low-point in 2011. Despite a 10% decline since September, the dollar is currently 16% stronger than its end-1987 trough. In contrast to a 57% depreciation in the 16 years from before its first devaluation to late 1987, the dollar on balance appreciated 16% on balance over the ensuing three and a half decades.

After peaking at 79.85 in the spring of 1995 and setting an even stronger all-time peak of 75.7 in October 2011, the yen was transformed into a weak currency by the Bank of Japan’s ultra-loose monetary policy. At a low of 151.94 in October 2021, the yen had lost half its dollar value in the span of ten years. Even now at 134 per dollar, the yen is 40% weaker than its April 1995 low, which is all the more extraordinary considering that Japan has struggled with deflation for a good part of that period.

Those believing that the inflation that emerged in the United States from the pandemic reflects the same dynamic as the painful inflation felt 4-5 decades ago have a theory with a glaring loose thread. When U.S. fiscal and monetary policies were central to the earlier inflationary experience, the dollar depreciated as one would have expected it to do. That has not happened this time.

Copyright 2023, Larry Greenberg. All rights reserved. No secondary distribution without express permission.

Tags:

ShareThis

Comments are closed.

css.php